Toronto Blue Jays (since 1977)

200 Greatest Toronto Blue Jays

  1. Dave Stieb p, 1979–1998 114
  2. Roy Halladay p, 1998–2013 100
  3. Jose Bautista rf, 2004–2018 77
  4. Tony Fernandez ss, 1983–2001 67
  5. Carlos Delgado 1b, 1993–2009 66
  6. Jesse Barfield rf, 1981–1992 57
  7. Jimmy Key p, 1984–1998 55
  8. Pat Hentgen p, 1991–2004 52
  9. Vernon Wells cf, 1999–2013 47
  10. Lloyd Moseby cf, 1980–1991 45
  11. Roger Clemens p, 1984–2007 45
  12. Devon White cf, 1985–2001 43
  13. Edwin Encarnacion 3b, 2005–2020 43
  14. Jim Clancy p, 1977–1991 43
  15. Roberto Alomar 2b, 1988–2004 41
  16. Juan Guzman p, 1991–2000 40
  17. Josh Donaldson 3b, 2010–2021 40
  18. Ernie Whitt c, 1976–1991 38
  19. John Olerud 1b, 1989–2005 38
  20. Fred McGriff 1b, 1986–2004 38
  21. Tom Henke p, 1982–1995 37
  22. Alex Rios rf, 2004–2015 35
  23. George Bell lf, 1981–1993 34
  24. Shannon Stewart lf, 1995–2008 30
  25. Aaron Hill 2b, 2005–2017 30
  26. David Wells p, 1987–2007 30
  27. Kelly Gruber 3b, 1984–1993 30
  28. Rance Mulliniks 3b, 1977–1992 27
  29. Mark Eichhorn p, 1982–1996 27
  30. Marcus Stroman p, 2014–2021 25
  31. Brett Lawrie 3b, 2011–2016 25
  32. Doyle Alexander p, 1971–1989 25
  33. Paul Quantrill p, 1992–2005 24
  34. Duane Ward p, 1986–1995 24
  35. Kevin Pillar cf, 2013–2021 23
  36. Shawn Green rf, 1993–2007 23
  37. Orlando Hudson 2b, 2002–2012 23
  38. Gregg Zaun c, 1995–2010 20
  39. Kelvim Escobar p, 1997–2009 20
  40. Bo Bichette ss, 2019–2021 20
  41. Ricky Romero p, 2009–2013 19
  42. Paul Molitor dh, 1978–1998 19
  43. Todd Stottlemyre p, 1988–2002 19
  44. J.A. Happ p, 2007–2021 19
  45. Scott Downs p, 2000–2014 19
  46. Marco Scutaro ss, 2002–2014 19
  47. Aaron Sanchez p, 2014–2021 19
  48. Casey Janssen p, 2006–2015 18
  49. Woody Williams p, 1993–2007 18
  50. Tony Castillo p, 1988–1998 18
  51. Willie Upshaw 1b, 1978–1988 18
  52. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 1b, 2019–2021 18
  53. Luis Leal p, 1980–1985 17
  54. Al Leiter p, 1987–2005 17
  55. Marco Estrada p, 2008–2019 17
  56. Shaun Marcum p, 2005–2015 16
  57. Jerry Garvin p, 1977–1982 16
  58. Lyle Overbay 1b, 2001–2014 16
  59. Robbie Ray p, 2014–2021 16
  60. Marcus Semien ss, 2013–2021 15
  61. Otto Velez rf, 1973–1983 14
  62. Scott Rolen 3b, 1996–2012 14
  63. Reed Johnson lf, 2003–2015 14
  64. Mike Timlin p, 1991–2008 14
  65. Yunel Escobar ss, 2007–2017 14
  66. Russell Martin c, 2006–2019 14
  67. Teoscar Hernandez lf, 2016–2021 14
  68. Adam Lind 1b, 2006–2017 14
  69. Hyun Jin Ryu p, 2013–2021 13
  70. Jose Cruz rf, 1997–2008 13
  71. Troy Glaus 3b, 1998–2010 13
  72. David Cone p, 1986–2003 13
  73. Brett Cecil p, 2009–2018 13
  74. Roberto Osuna p, 2015–2020 13
  75. Jason Frasor p, 2004–2015 12
  76. Joe Carter lf, 1983–1998 12
  77. Damaso Garcia 2b, 1978–1989 12
  78. Roy Howell 3b, 1974–1984 12
  79. Colby Rasmus cf, 2009–2018 12
  80. Alex Gonzalez ss, 1994–2006 12
  81. Cavan Biggio 2b, 2019–2021 11
  82. Chris Carpenter p, 1997–2012 11
  83. Manuel Lee ss, 1985–1995 11
  84. Jose Reyes ss, 2003–2018 10
  85. Eric Hinske 3b, 2002–2013 10
  86. B.J. Ryan p, 1999–2009 10
  87. Tony Batista 3b, 1996–2007 10
  88. Mark Buehrle p, 2000–2015 10
  89. Roy Lee Jackson p, 1977–1986 10
  90. Lourdes Gurriel Jr. lf, 2018–2021 10
  91. Ted Lilly p, 1999–2013 9
  92. Billy Koch p, 1999–2004 9
  93. John Cerutti p, 1985–1991 9
  94. Aaron Loup p, 2012–2021 9
  95. Devon Travis 2b, 2015–2018 9
  96. A.J. Burnett p, 1999–2015 9
  97. John McDonald ss, 1999–2014 9
  98. Pat Borders c, 1988–2005 9
  99. Brandon Morrow p, 2007–2018 9
  100. Jordan Romano p, 2019–2021 9
  101. Justin Speier p, 1998–2009 8
  102. Justin Smoak 1b, 2010–2020 8
  103. Cliff Johnson dh, 1972–1986 8
  104. R.A. Dickey p, 2001–2017 8
  105. Frank Castillo p, 1991–2005 8
  106. Frank Catalanotto lf, 1997–2010 8
  107. Raul Mondesi rf, 1993–2005 8
  108. Darrin Fletcher c, 1989–2002 8
  109. Troy Tulowitzki ss, 2006–2019 7
  110. Dave Collins lf, 1975–1990 7
  111. Alex Gonzalez ss, 1998–2014 7
  112. Tom Candiotti p, 1983–1999 7
  113. Tom Underwood p, 1974–1984 7
  114. Ed Sprague 3b, 1991–2001 7
  115. Dave Winfield rf, 1973–1995 7
  116. Pete Walker p, 1995–2006 7
  117. Buck Martinez c, 1969–1986 7
  118. Danny Jansen c, 2018–2021 7
  119. Gustavo Chacin p, 2004–2010 7
  120. Charlie O'Brien c, 1985–2000 6
  121. Joey McLaughlin p, 1977–1984 6
  122. Pete Vuckovich p, 1975–1986 6
  123. Dan Plesac p, 1986–2003 6
  124. Mike Flanagan p, 1975–1992 6
  125. Victor Cruz p, 1978–1983 6
  126. Danny Cox p, 1983–1995 6
  127. Junior Felix rf, 1989–1994 6
  128. Melky Cabrera lf, 2005–2019 6
  129. Randal Grichuk rf, 2014–2021 6
  130. Esteban Loaiza p, 1995–2008 6
  131. Santiago Espinal 3b, 2020–2021 6
  132. Alek Manoah p, 2021 6
  133. Ryan Tepera p, 2015–2021 6
  134. Ryan Borucki p, 2018–2021 6
  135. Carlos Villanueva p, 2006–2016 6
  136. Ken Giles p, 2014–2020 6
  137. David Price p, 2008–2021 6
  138. Homer Bush 2b, 1997–2004 5
  139. Candy Maldonado rf, 1981–1995 5
  140. Jesse Litsch p, 2007–2011 5
  141. Mike Willis p, 1977–1981 5
  142. Shawn Camp p, 2004–2014 5
  143. Joe Inglett 2b, 2006–2011 5
  144. Ryan Goins 2b, 2013–2020 5
  145. Darren Oliver p, 1993–2013 5
  146. Jeremy Accardo p, 2005–2012 5
  147. Greg Myers c, 1987–2005 5
  148. Dave Lemanczyk p, 1973–1980 5
  149. Dominic Leone p, 2014–2021 5
  150. Freddy Galvis ss, 2012–2021 5
  151. Matt Shoemaker p, 2013–2021 5
  152. Garth Iorg 3b, 1978–1987 5
  153. Dale Murray p, 1974–1985 5
  154. Barry Bonnell lf, 1977–1986 5
  155. Tim Crabtree p, 1995–2001 5
  156. Jesse Carlson p, 2008–2010 5
  157. A.J. Cole p, 2015–2021 5
  158. Rafael Dolis p, 2011–2021 5
  159. Eric Sogard 2b, 2010–2021 4
  160. Chris Woodward ss, 1999–2011 4
  161. George Springer rf, 2014–2021 4
  162. Seunghwan Oh p, 2016–2019 4
  163. Nelson Liriano 2b, 1987–1998 4
  164. Orlando Merced rf, 1990–2003 4
  165. Paul Spoljaric p, 1994–2000 4
  166. Aquilino Lopez p, 2003–2008 4
  167. Marc Rzepczynski p, 2009–2018 4
  168. Brandon League p, 2004–2014 4
  169. Tom Buskey p, 1973–1980 4
  170. Dave Bush p, 2004–2013 4
  171. Jesse Jefferson p, 1973–1981 4
  172. Rod Barajas c, 1999–2012 4
  173. Bob Bailor rf, 1975–1985 4
  174. Al Woods lf, 1977–1986 4
  175. Joaquin Benoit p, 2001–2017 4
  176. Taijuan Walker p, 2013–2021 4
  177. Jackson Todd p, 1977–1981 4
  178. John Mayberry 1b, 1968–1982 4
  179. Tom Murphy p, 1968–1979 4
  180. Kelly Johnson 2b, 2005–2016 4
  181. Tim Mayza p, 2017–2021 4
  182. Bob File p, 2001–2004 4
  183. Jim Acker p, 1983–1992 4
  184. Jason Kershner p, 2002–2004 3
  185. Jim Gott p, 1982–1995 3
  186. Matt Stairs rf, 1992–2011 3
  187. Mark Hendrickson p, 2002–2011 3
  188. Alan Ashby c, 1973–1989 3
  189. Darren Hall p, 1994–1998 3
  190. Frank Menechino 2b, 1999–2005 3
  191. Tyler Clippard p, 2007–2021 3
  192. Chad Jenkins p, 2012–2015 3
  193. Henderson Alvarez III p, 2011–2017 3
  194. Ron Fairly 1b, 1958–1978 3
  195. Steven Matz p, 2015–2021 3
  196. Dustin McGowan p, 2005–2017 3
  197. Josh Phelps dh, 2000–2008 3
  198. Aledmys Díaz ss, 2016–2021 3
  199. J.P. Arencibia c, 2010–2015 3

Greatest Toronto Blue Jays by Hall Rating

  1. Dave Stieb
  2. Roy Halladay
  3. Jose Bautista
  4. Tony Fernandez
  5. Carlos Delgado

All-Time Team by Hall Rating with the Toronto Blue Jays (known issues and limitations)

  1. C: Ernie Whitt (38)
  2. 1B: Carlos Delgado (66)
  3. 2B: Roberto Alomar (41)
  4. 3B: Edwin Encarnacion (43)
  5. SS: Tony Fernandez (67)
  6. LF: George Bell (34)
  7. CF: Vernon Wells (47)
  8. RF: Jose Bautista (77)
  9. P: Dave Stieb (114)

Bench

  1. RF: Jesse Barfield (57)
  2. CF: Lloyd Moseby (45)
  3. CF: Devon White (43)
  4. 3B: Josh Donaldson (40)
  5. 1B: John Olerud (38)
  6. 1B: Fred McGriff (38)
  7. RF: Alex Rios (35)

Bullpen

  1. P: Roy Halladay (100)
  2. P: Jimmy Key (55)
  3. P: Pat Hentgen (52)
  4. P: Roger Clemens (45)
  5. P: Jim Clancy (43)
  6. P: Juan Guzman (40)
  7. P: Tom Henke (37)
  8. P: David Wells (30)
  9. P: Mark Eichhorn (27)