Mel Stottlemyre

Position
Pitcher
Years
1964–1974
Hall Rating
72
Next Ballot
Mel Stottlemyre is next eligible for the Hall of Fame via the Classic Baseball Era Committee in 2025.
Peak
47%
Longevity
53%

Rankings by Hall Rating

Franchise Contributions by Hall Rating

Career Statistics

Win-Value Statistics
WAR WAA adjWAR adjWAA
About the stats
43.0 20.1 43.2 18.9
Run-Value Statistics
Bat Run DP Fld Pos Pit
-66 -3 -1 0 0 144
Season-by-Season Statistics
Year Team WAA WAR
1964 NYY 2.3 3.0
1965 NYY 4.6 6.9
1966 NYY -0.5 1.6
1967 NYY 1.6 3.7
1968 NYY 3.2 5.6
1969 NYY 3.5 6.1
1970 NYY 1.9 4.3
1971 NYY 1.4 3.8
1972 NYY 0.9 3.3
1973 NYY 1.6 4.1
1974 NYY -0.4 0.6
BBWAA Voting Results
Year Percentage
1980
0.8%
Similar in Value to Mel Stottlemyre
Player (Hall Rating) Similarity
John Candelaria (78) 67
Deacon Phillippe (65) 70
Sam Leever (74) 78
Tom Candiotti (79) 88
Lon Warneke (81) 89
Ed Reulbach (74) 90
Andy Messersmith (73) 91
Jeff Pfeffer (76) 93
Jon Lester (82) 94
Ned Garver (77) 97
Jake Peavy (72) 99
Jack Chesbro (78) 100
Adam Wainwright (86) 103
Rube Walberg (67) 103
Javier Vazquez (85) 106
Burt Hooton (67) 107
Curt Davis (76) 109
Pink Hawley (67) 109
Thornton Lee (66) 110
Dutch Leonard (69) 110